The Lowest Form

back to bloglist

Sandy Higgs's Column

Entries
17 November, 2009, 12:51
Gallows humor

With the Russian Constitutional Court now considering whether or not capital punishment should be reintroduced in Russia after a 13-year moratorium, I’ve been toying with some headlines for the story. “Capital punishment gets death sentence”, “Fate of capital punishment hangs in the air”, “Death penalty advocates in for a shock”, “Which way does CP seem to be-heading?”, “Chamber reconsiders chamber” etc. Naturally, all of these are far too flippant for an issue of such moment.

Read more

I am an opponent of the death penalty – I feel aggrieved for those affected by violent crime, but I also don’t think “an eye for an eye” is the way to rid the world of it, especially given the fallibility of law enforcement and the court system (in every country, I mean).There are humans involved. It also doesn’t seem to have fixed anything in the time we’ve been on the planet, except perhaps to give some hollow sense of vengeance for the victims’ relatives.

Now that my cards are on the table as being “soft on crime” (as some will no doubt say) because I’m a “bleeding heart” (fair enough - I agree and I’m proud of my compassion), it’s still hard for me to avoid making jokes about the whole situation. Or indeed most situations.

The Internet and mobile phones have made spreading jokes much easier than it used to be. I had received emails containing jokes about Michael Jackson’s death before I even knew he was dead. That’s how I found out, in fact. This is an exception, of course. Most humour regarding celebrity deaths give a period of grace of at least a day or two before surfacing and making their way around the inboxes.

So what makes MJ any different? Well, the poor guy had become a parody of himself in life, and had been accused (and was therefore guilty in the minds of many) of some pretty heinous crimes against children. His talent notwithstanding, these attributes were apparently enough for any thoughts of a joke amnesty to be abandoned in his case. Elvis Presley had also become a parody of himself, but jokes about him were limited (after a few days, or perhaps years) to his accent, his weight, his diet of fried peanut butter sandwiches and his clothing. All fairly obvious and benign. John Lennon is still off-limits (maybe he’s just not good for material), although there are some unkind gags still being made about his wife (Dennis Leary and Ricky Gervais are two I’ve heard do this), which is hardly the same thing. MJ, in the same stratosphere of superstardom as the other two, was afforded none of the same reverence because he had pushed himself past the point of being lovable for many people, with the notable exceptions of the Philippines’ prison population and some zealots who were queuing out the front of the US embassy in Moscow to lay flowers – weirdness attracts weirdness, I guess.

Several famous people have passed away this year (OK, I hate that expression too. Let’s go even more politically correct and say they’ve become “mortally challenged”), many having to wait for at least 3-4 days before a single joke was told about them. Some didn’t even rate that level of reverence – for instance, I haven’t heard a single Patrick Swayze joke. Let’s try shall we, and see who we can offend? How about “Apparently now Patrick’s been buried he’s still dirty, but no longer dancing” or “Did you hear that Patrick’s using the Stanislavsky method for his role in Ghost 2”? Lame. In fairness to me, he wasn’t a particularly comical character in general and he died of a horrible, painful disease, which hardly makes for rich comic pickings. MJ died as he lived – in strange circumstances, which makes it far easier to poke fun at. Does that mean we should? Why not? Someone will always be offended by something (one only has to read comments below just about any blog, this one included, to know that, but that’s for another column). So why walk on eggshells?

It seems to me that laughter from tragedy is a long-established method of dealing with the uncomfortable. Russians are usually pretty good at this, but then they’ve had their fair share of tough times. Of course, they’re allowed to do it to themselves, but are not fond of others poking fun at them. Who is? Perhaps this is one of the boundaries of black humor: it’s not quite as funny if you’re the one experiencing the tragedy, unless it’s actually you making the joke. Sure, not everyone finds solace in this kind of levity, but for those who do, it can be as cathartic and therapeutic as a visit to a counsellor. Cheaper too.

I once witnessed a guy commit suicide from a bridge, and I subsequently made a police report giving my account of events as I had seen them. The policeman thanked me and acknowledged that this was not a pleasant thing to have observed. His recommendation: “Try to make jokes about it. That’s what we do, and we see some pretty horrific stuff.” I’m not sure if I managed to come up with anything remotely risible regarding the “jumper”, but I did take the police officer’s words on board. Working with the water police can be a drag, after all.

The plethora of jokes regarding the death of the Princess of Wales, in 1997, was a classic example of the sheer shock at the event and the subsequent outpouring of grief finding an outlet. Or perhaps an antidote. To those not entirely enamoured with the late-Princess, the extent of the mourning by some was a bit overwhelming and, some would say, over-the-top. My personal favourite was, “Did you hear that seven paparazzi have been killed in a Paris tunnel? They were being chased by Dannii Minogue.” This captured the argument about the right to privacy and played on the event itself without making direct reference to those who died. Dannii’s also been annoying me since she was a child star on an Australian variety show, so I could relate to the paparazzi in the joke – she’s hard to escape.

One of the pitfalls of the genre is, of course, the number of comedians and radio and television hosts who have a vested interest in creating throwaway lines about the misfortunes of others. Usually there is a sense of self-censorship in this task – not in the creative or brainstorming process, rather in what actually makes it into their routines. However, even these lines are occasionally blurred by those somewhat removed from the tragedy and, moreover, from their audience's sensibilities.

Whatever the “period of grace” is between a tragedy occurring and the creation of jokes about it, it should be noted that any group of words on the subject could be considered a death sentence. I guess it’s all in the execution.

27 October, 2009, 17:49
Putting it off
12 October, 2009, 17:49
When words fail
About author

A Sydneysider missing the beach, Sandy Higgs performed comedy in more than 3 living rooms before being exiled to Moscow for crimes against humor.

There's no particular point to this column, except hopefully to add a little levity to some otherwise serious subjects. The title "The Lowest Form" is supposed to be completed as "the lowest form of wit", referring to sarcasm. However, the reader may elect to change the last words to "of life", or whatever takes his/her fancy.